“Gunner Palace” … PG-13?
Drudge splashed this Variety.com article, which underscores what I’ve been harping on (off and on) on this blog. And that is that as parents, we have the responsibility to act like parents.
“It’s PG-13, my kids is 14, I’m sure it’s fine.”
Right.
The MPAA has just rated “Gunner Palace” PG-13, and it includes numerous instances of expletives (in a war zone), including FU**, SH** and A**HOLE. If that’s what you want burning into the permanent recording devices known as a child’s brain, fine, but at least pay attention to what they’re watching and doing.
And don’t trust any external regulatory or pseudo-self-regulating voluntary body with the welfare of your children.
The arguments in favor of the PG-13 rating are basically that it’s a reality-based documentary. The Daily Brief says:
To me, profanity in a documentary, particularly one about the military, is akin to full frontal nudity in National Geographic. Should we also be taking that out of children’s reach?
The problem is, it’s not that an R rating is a punishment, it’s supposed to give you an accurate representation of the content of the film. And while folks, such as WindOfChange, think it is absurd to rate this film R, the fact remains that if ratings are simply political, they may as well be thrown out.
MPAA says that an R rating means:
In the opinion of the Rating Board, this film definitely contains some adult material. Parents are strongly urged to find out more about this film before they allow their children to accompany them.
An R-rated film may include hard language, or tough violence, or nudity within sensual scenes, or drug abuse or other elements, or a combination of some of the above, so that parents are counseled, in advance, to take this advisory rating very seriously. Parents must find out more about an R-rated movie before they allow their teenagers to view it.
And a war film with lots of expletives surely falls into the category of “parents, you want to find out more about this movie before you allow your teenagers to view it.” And it may well be that the decision you make is that it is appropriate for your child. But the MPAA should not be making that decision for you.
UPDATE: On an almost related note, a school in the UK has banned kids from playing tag becuase it’s too dangerous:
A SCHOOL has banned children from playing tag — claiming it is too DANGEROUS.
Shocked parents were told pupils — aged from five to nine — must drop the centuries-old chase game.
The parents are up in arms, er, upset about it.
http://myopiczeal.blogsome.com/2005/02/26/gunner-palace-pg-13/trackback/
You'll love Woods' Edge at Salt Creek Golf Retreat, Brown County, Indiana.







Jack Valenti issued a comment Wednesday on the PG-13 rating that the documentary “Gunner Palace” won on appeal last week.
Comment by James — March 3, 2005 @ 8:27 am
March 3, 2005
“Gunner Palace” Continued.
Reader James, has pointed me to the fact that National Association of Theatre Owners president John […]
Pingback by Myopic Zeal :: “Gunner Palace” Continued. — March 3, 2005 @ 9:37 am
I have seen this film and if I were thinking about my children seeing the film, I would reflect on the language issue and I would weigh the merit of the film vs the F word. I think I would choose to prepare them for the rough language of the war setting and let them go. I have more control in this case than I do on a friend’s Xbox or MTV. They are exposed to the F word at the elementary school, definitely the middle school, the school bus, soccer game, mall, and street. The bigger issue seems to be about war and the notion they could end up in one. Gunner Palace is a wake up call. Yes the soldiers are young, both genders, not very protected, scared, brave, and also pretty darn familiar with the F word.
Comment by larry — March 8, 2005 @ 5:37 pm
testcomment864
Comment by testanchor964 — October 15, 2005 @ 5:50 pm
blackjack rules
In your free time, check the sites dedicated to internet blackjack learn how to play blackjack
Trackback by blackjack rules — November 17, 2005 @ 10:15 am
anal fingering
In your free time, visit some relevant information on wet thongs brazilian beach girls
Trackback by anal fingering — November 20, 2005 @ 1:41 pm
http://www.uncg.edu/art/courses/rwrice/cgi/wwwboard/messages5/4434.html clothinggamessickening
Comment by forever — February 8, 2006 @ 9:32 pm
online texas hold em tournament
endows diffusers dither
Trackback by online texas hold em tournament — March 13, 2006 @ 7:16 pm